Question 1

How is a shawl pin different from a brooch?

Accepted Answer

A shawl pin is functional: a long pin (usually 3-5 inches) that threads through a knit wrap or cardigan to hold it closed, so it needs a smooth point that won't split yarn. A brooch is shorter, pins onto one layer of fabric as decoration, and uses a bar-and-hook clasp. Shawl pins also come in penannular and magnetic styles that a brooch never uses. Handmade shawl pins run about $15-$110 depending on metal.

Question 2

What is a penannular shawl pin?

Accepted Answer

A penannular pin is the Celtic-style design with an open ring and a free-moving straight pin. You push the pin through both layers, rotate the ring, and the wrap's own tension locks it in place — no clasp to fail. Knitters love it because it holds heavy wraps securely and slides out without snagging. Handmade brass, pewter, and bronze penannular pins typically cost $20-$50 and are a favorite gift for shawl knitters.

Question 3

Will a shawl pin snag delicate or lace-weight yarn?

Accepted Answer

Not if the point is finished well. The single most important thing to check is a smooth, polished tip with no burr — run a fingernail down it in the listing photos or ask the maker. For mohair, lace-weight, and fine silk, magnetic shawl pins are the safest choice because nothing pierces the fibers. For worsted and bulky knits, a standard stick-and-loop or penannular pin holds better.

Question 4

What size shawl pin should I choose?

Accepted Answer

Match the pin length to the knit weight. A 4-5 inch pin suits chunky garter-stitch wraps, blanket scarves, and bulky cardigans where the fabric is thick. A 3-3.5 inch pin works for fingering and lace-weight shawls so it doesn't overwhelm the fabric. Most handmade pins list overall length and pin diameter; a thinner pin shaft passes through fine knits more easily.

Question 5

Are shawl pins a good gift for knitters and crocheters?

Accepted Answer

Yes — they're one of the most-appreciated gifts for makers because a knitter who spent weeks on a shawl needs a way to wear it. Pair a handmade pin with a skein of nice yarn or a finished wrap. Wood and antler pins suit rustic, hand-spun projects; brass and sterling suit dressier lace shawls. Many makers offer initial engraving for $5-$15, which turns a $20-$40 pin into a personalized keepsake.

Question 6

How long do handmade shawl pins take to ship?

Accepted Answer

Stock pins from independent makers usually ship in 3-7 business days. Made-to-order metalwork — hand-hammered brass, forged pewter, or sterling — and any custom engraving typically add 1-3 weeks, since each piece is finished by hand. If it's a holiday or birthday gift, check the maker's current lead time and any cut-off date in the listing before ordering.

Shawl Pins That Won't Snag Your Knits

Explore by interest

Recently explored

Inspired by what you viewed

Shawl Pins That Won't Snag Your Knits

There's even more for you to discover

Explore by interest

Recently explored

Inspired by what you viewed

Related themes

More in Pins & Clips